Cyber Security for Medical devices is an important topic, and one that has become more important over the last few years as uplifts to the EUMDR and the FDA process for 510k compliance have been implemented. It is now more relevant than ever to ensure that cyber security is embedded into your processes, whether you are implementing software as a medical device or traditional medical device requirements
What are the key requirements for Cyber Security for Medical Devices?
- Security through development processes
- Hazard and risk analysis
- Penetration and fuzz testing
- Data and Security by design
- Bill of materials
What are the requirements within the standards?
EUMDR (European Union Medical Device Regulation)
- Risk Management: EUMDR requires medical device manufacturers to perform a comprehensive risk analysis as part of their technical documentation. This includes evaluating cybersecurity risks that could impact patient safety and device performance. It involves assessing potential threats and implementing controls to mitigate identified risks.
- Security by Design: EUMDR emphasizes the importance of integrating cybersecurity measures throughout the design and development processes. This includes secure software development practices, data encryption, and secure communication protocols.
- Data Protection: Since EUMDR applies within the EU, compliance with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) is mandatory when handling personal data. Medical devices that store or transmit patient data must ensure data confidentiality, integrity, and availability.
- Post-market Surveillance: EUMDR requires manufacturers to establish post-market surveillance systems. This includes monitoring for cybersecurity vulnerabilities, reporting incidents, and updating devices as necessary to address emerging threats.
- Technical Documentation: Technical files must include a description of the cybersecurity measures implemented, including risk management strategies and a detailed explanation of how the device's software maintains its integrity and security.
FDA 510(k) (Premarket Notification)
- Premarket Submission Requirements: For medical devices with software components or those that are connected, the FDA requires a detailed cybersecurity plan as part of the 510(k) submission. This includes:
- Threat Modeling and Risk Assessment: Manufacturers must identify cybersecurity risks, assess their impact on patient safety, and provide a plan for managing those risks.
- Cybersecurity Design Controls: The FDA expects manufacturers to demonstrate that cybersecurity measures are integrated into the design of the device. This includes employing encryption, strong authentication mechanisms, and secure software updates.
- Guidance for Premarket Submissions: The FDA’s guidance document, Content of Premarket Submissions for Management of Cybersecurity in Medical Devices, outlines specific expectations, including:
- Identification of Security Risks: A comprehensive list of risks and how they are addressed.
- Justification for Cybersecurity Functions: Clear explanations of why particular security measures were chosen and how they contribute to the device's safety.
- Security Updates and Patching Procedures: Plans for how the device will be updated in response to new vulnerabilities or threats after it’s on the market.
- Labeling and Documentation: Devices must include cybersecurity-related information for users, such as recommended security controls (e.g., firewalls, access controls) and instructions for securely maintaining and updating the device.
- Postmarket Guidance: The FDA also provides guidance for postmarket cybersecurity, which emphasizes monitoring, vulnerability management, and addressing new threats as they arise. It requires that manufacturers have a process for timely software updates and patches when new vulnerabilities are identified.
Both EUMDR and the FDA require manufacturers to identify and mitigate cybersecurity risks throughout the device lifecycle. They emphasise incorporating security measures during the design and development phases rather than treating cybersecurity as an afterthought and both emphasise the importance of postmarket surveillance, including monitoring for vulnerabilities and providing software updates or patches to ensure continued security.
Top 5 tips for Medical Device Cyber Security from our expert
What are the Key Requirements for Cybersecurity for Medical Devices?
To ensure the safety, effectiveness, and security of medical devices, manufacturers must address several critical cybersecurity requirements throughout the device's lifecycle. These include considerations during development, risk management, testing, secure design, and transparency of components. Here’s a detailed breakdown of each key aspect:
Security Through Development Processes
Secure Software Development Lifecycle (SDLC):
Implementing a secure SDLC ensures that security is integrated at each stage of software development. This involves secure coding practices, regular code reviews, vulnerability scanning, and automated testing. It also includes creating a plan for managing security patches and updates once the device is in use.
Action Plan:
- Define security requirements at the start of the project.
- Use tools like OWASP Dependency-Check to scan libraries for known vulnerabilities.
- Incorporate security checks into Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment (CI/CD) pipelines using tools like GitHub Actions or GitLab CI.
Secure Configuration Management:
Managing changes to software configurations helps maintain the security posture of the device. It ensures that any changes to software or system settings are tracked, reviewed, and securely implemented.
Action Plan:
- Use version control tools like Git for tracking changes.
- Implement configuration management tools like Ansible or Puppet to automate secure settings.
- Establish a change review process to evaluate the security impact of software changes.
Verification and Validation:
The security of software and system architecture must be validated against cybersecurity requirements through thorough testing and verification. This ensures that the system performs as expected under different threat scenarios.
Action Plan:
- Create a testing plan that includes unit tests, integration tests, and security tests.
- Enable Dependabot if you use GitHub to cover static code analysis easily.
Perform regular code reviews using GitHub, GitLab, or Bitbucket to ensure adherence to secure coding standards.
Hazard and Risk Analysis
Threat Modelling:
Identifying potential threats and attack vectors that could compromise the device's security is essential. Threat modelling helps to anticipate where vulnerabilities might be exploited and to prioritise them based on the risk to patient safety and device functionality.
Action Plan:
- Use OWASP Threat Dragon to identify potential attack vectors.
- Develop Data Flow Diagrams (DFDs) to understand data movement within the device and identify where threats could occur.
- Regularly update threat models as the device evolves.
Risk Assessment (ISO 14971):
Conducting risk assessments is vital to evaluate the potential impact of cybersecurity threats. This involves quantifying risks, implementing mitigation measures, and documenting the effectiveness of these measures to ensure that residual risks are acceptable.
Action Plan:
- Follow ISO 14971 standards for risk management, using templates to document risks, controls, and mitigation measures.
- Create a simple spreadsheet and start analysing your risks associated to your product
- Hold periodic risk review meetings to reassess risks and their mitigation status.
Failure Mode Analysis:
Examining how potential failures due to cybersecurity vulnerabilities could impact patient safety and device operation helps in defining appropriate controls and responses.
Actionable Plan:
- Perform Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) with tools to evaluate potential failure modes.
- Document failure modes, their effects, and potential mitigations in a centralised database or spreadsheet.
- Update the FMEA after significant software or hardware changes.
Penetration and Fuzz Testing for Medical Device Compliance
Penetration Testing:
Penetration testing involves simulating real-world cyber-attacks to identify vulnerabilities that could be exploited by malicious actors. It is a critical part of verifying the effectiveness of security controls and identifying weaknesses before the device is released.
Actionable Plan:
- Hire certified penetration testers (e.g., CEH, OSCP) or use in-house expertise.
- Use automated tools like Nessus, Burp Suite, or OWASP ZAP for initial scans.
- Conduct manual testing to probe areas identified by automated scans.
- Document findings, prioritise based on risk, and track remediation actions.
Fuzz Testing:
Fuzz testing involves inputting unexpected or random data into the device's software to uncover potential vulnerabilities, such as buffer overflows or other memory-related issues. This testing helps ensure that the software can handle unexpected inputs without compromising its functionality or security.
Action Plan:
- Use fuzz testing tools like AFL (American Fuzzy Lop) or Peach Fuzzer to automate input testing.
- Test input fields, APIs, and communication protocols for unexpected behavior.
- Set up automated fuzzing in CI/CD environments to catch vulnerabilities before deployment.
Dynamic and Static Analysis:
Utilising tools to analyse code both while it is running (dynamic analysis) and in its non-executing state (static analysis) can help identify security flaws early in the development cycle, making it easier to address them before they pose risks in the field.
Action Plan:
- Use OWASP Dependency-Check for static analysis of software dependencies.
- Use Veracode or Fortify for deeper static analysis.
- Integrate dynamic analysis tools like OWASP ZAP into testing environments to assess running applications.
Data and Security by Design in Medical Device Cybersecurity
Encryption:
Protecting data at rest and in transit using strong encryption methods helps ensure data confidentiality and integrity. This is particularly important for protecting sensitive patient data from unauthorised access or tampering.
Action Plan:
- Use OpenSSL for implementing encryption protocols.
- Implement AES-256 for data at rest and TLS 1.2/1.3 for data in transit.
- Regularly review and update encryption methods to align with current best practices.
Authentication and Access Control:
Implementing multi-factor authentication and robust access control mechanisms ensures that only authorised users can access the device or its data. It also helps prevent unauthorised changes to device settings or software.
Action Plan:
- Use OAuth 2.0 and OpenID Connect for secure user authentication.
- Implement multi-factor authentication (MFA) using tools like Authy or Okta.
- Define role-based access control (RBAC) policies and enforce them with Azure AD or AWS IAM for cloud-connected devices.
Secure Communication Protocols:
Ensuring that all communications between the device and other systems or networks are encrypted and secure helps to prevent data interception or tampering. Protocols such as TLS (Transport Layer Security) can be used for secure communication.
Action Plan:
- Use libraries like mTLS (Mutual TLS) for secure device-to-server communication.
- Regularly perform security reviews of communication protocols using Wireshark.
- Document and review all communication paths in threat models and ensure that protocols align with security policies.
Secure Boot and Firmware Integrity:
Secure boot mechanisms ensure that the device only runs trusted software by verifying digital signatures before loading firmware or software. This prevents the device from being compromised by unauthorised or tampered firmware.
Action Plan:
- Implement secure boot using hardware security modules (HSMs).
- Use cryptographic signing tools like GPG for firmware signing.
- Generate and review checksums to ensure the integrity of firmware during updates.
Building a Bill of Materials (BOM) for Medical Device Compliance
Software Bill of Materials (SBOM):
An SBOM is a list of all software components, libraries, and dependencies used within the device. It is crucial for tracking vulnerabilities in third-party components, ensuring that all elements are up-to-date, and quickly identifying affected components in case of newly discovered vulnerabilities.
Action Plan:
- Use tools like Syft or CycloneDX to automatically generate an SBOM for each software build.
- If you have a requirements.txt or similar, you can manually create an SBOM
- Include details of all open-source and third-party libraries, including version numbers and licenses.
- Store SBOMs in a version-controlled repository (e.g., GitHub or Bitbucket) for traceability.
Transparency and Traceability:
Providing an SBOM allows regulators, customers, and users to understand the software dependencies within a device. This transparency aids in maintaining security throughout the device's lifecycle and supports incident response by making it easier to assess the impact of a vulnerability.
Action Plan:
- Share SBOMs with regulators and customers through secure portals or as part of technical documentation.
- Implement an internal process to review and update the SBOM with every software release or update.
Vulnerability Management:
Continuous monitoring of vulnerabilities in components listed in the SBOM is crucial. It ensures that any discovered weaknesses in third-party software can be promptly addressed through patches or updates.
Action Plan:
- Use Dependabot for GitHub or Snyk for continuous monitoring of SBOM components for vulnerabilities.
- Regularly review advisories from NVD (National Vulnerability Database) and CVE lists.
- Develop a process for prioritising and applying patches to address vulnerabilities as they are identified.
Curious to know more? Take advantage of a FREE 30-minute strategy call with our Founder, Harrison Mussell. Talk about your security posture and help you discover critical areas for improvement, or having problems with a certain compliance control Harrison can advise you — no strings attached.
Want to know more about Periculo and our offerings Contact Us
Image Designed by vectorjuice / Freepik
.svg)
